Chamber Voice

Tough Year Ahead But We Have the Tools to Succeed

2012 will be another tough year. Political turmoil in the Eurozone and, at home, falling consumer confidence as Government spending cuts continue to bite and the labour market contracts will  dent business confidence. Accessing affordable finance is challenging for many companies and motivating workforces is difficult. There are no easy fixes: just hard work, innovation, collaboration, and a dose of good fortune. This region has businesses that have already risen to the challenge and will continue to do so. Michelin and GSK are the high-profile local successes we all know about, but they are not unique. Kangaroo Self Storage, GA Engineering, MTC Media and Axeon are just a few examples of other Chamber members that have prospered in 2011.

We will benefit from major developments planned or underway in the region, opportunities we have because people had the foresight and courage to make long-term strategic plans to transform the local economy, through life sciences, the Dundee Waterfront Project, Carnoustie Country, the V&A and the Angus Centre for Enterprise. More recently we have all been excited because we could be a significant renewable energy hub. The timescales over which these initiatives bring new investment and jobs here will vary and, in some cases, will be medium and long-term. But they will bring jobs and investment, and the big challenge, particularly for the public agencies that are in the lead in delivering the projects, is to get in front of local companies to inform and educate them, so they know what opportunities are coming and they can get ready to take advantage. Life sciences has been a great success story for this area because of the really effective collaboration and joint planning that the key organisations like NHS Tayside, Dundee City Council and the University of Dundee achieved. That model for 'joined up decision making' has served us well in the past and will do so again in 2012.

The Chamber expects the Government to play its part in supporting our members. Global trade is still rising.  This means more international opportunities than ever before and effective backing from the Scottish Government will be critical to winning that business.  The Scottish Government is spending a bigger proportion of its budget on infrastructure projects but that spend has to filter down to local firms. The Government must deliver a competitive tax regime in 2012. Business Rates could rise by nearly 6% in April 2012. That will damage the economy by making businesses less likely to invest. And they should re-visit their plans to subject colleges to swingeing budget cuts because reducing investment in future skills makes no economic sense. Dundee & Angus Chamber of Commerce will also raise its game to support local businesses with, amongst other things, an Energy Forum and a Tourism Group, to share market intelligence within these future growth sectors.

In summary, a tough economic climate will challenge everyone in 2012 but there is no reason why companies in Dundee and Angus can't succeed if the businesses themselves, the chamber of commerce, the local public agencies and the Scottish Government do our jobs properly and work together better than we ever have before.

 

 

DACC Writes to Scottish Government Raising Concerns Over College Funding Announcement

Alan Mitchell has written to John Swinney MSP, Cabinet Secretary for Finance & Sustainable Growth, regarding the cuts announced to funding for FE colleges.

I hope that this note finds you well.

 

I am very concerned that the cuts you have announced to funding for FE colleges risks doing damage to the economic prospects for Dundee and Angus.  Colleges play a vital part in creating the skilled workforce that the economy needs.  They will play an especially critical role in producing the skills we need to give Scotland a global leadership role in renewable energy and to keep us at the forefront of this growing industry.

 

I can see no obvious justification for subjecting colleges to such severe cuts when they have never been so important in getting the economy growing.  The cuts that colleges will have to bear appear disproportionately large relative to other parts of the public sector and they seem to entirely contradict the Scottish Government’s public announcements that growing the economy sustainably is its ‘number one’ priority.

 

I know the management teams at our two local colleges – Dundee and Angus – very well.   I would describe them as ‘down to earth’ and ‘grounded’.  So, when they tell me that the scale of the cuts that they will have to make, on top of the massive cuts they have already absorbed this year, threatens their ability to meet the needs of the students, businesses and communities that they serve, then I take those warnings very seriously. 

 

This Chamber is first and foremost an SME, and like all SMEs we run a ‘lean’, cost-effective business.  I expect the public sector to do the same when it spends taxpayers’ money, and if I thought for one minute that Angus College or Dundee College were inefficient and wasted public money then I would have no hesitation in supporting your announcement. 

 

But, because of the close working relationship we have with them, I know that is not the case.  They are already very efficient organisations and they are already in the forefront of collaborative working with other colleges and higher education institutions.  The First Minister acknowledged this when he opened Dundee College’s Gardyne Campus last week.   So, in the case of Dundee and Angus, I fail to see how the planned cuts can do anything other than threaten the quality and quantity of their course provision.    Even the best management teams can’t cut waste if there is no waste left to cut.

 

I understand that the UK Government’s decision to freeze Council tax in England will result in extra Barnett Consequential Funding for Scotland.  I urge you to use some of this money to make good the cuts you announced in your budget, so that Dundee College and Angus College can continue the great work they do to deliver quality education to their students, and provide the skilled workforce that allow local businesses grow and generate the tax revenues that you need to fund the social programmes that are so important to you.

 

I look forward to receiving your comments on this matter but want to conclude by reminding you that my President, Chris Lundie, wrote to you earlier this year inviting you back to Dundee for another meeting with our members.   I hope that you will be able to accept. 

 

Alan Mitchell

Chief Executive

 

 

 

Scottish Chambers of Commerce Lobbying Update

At DACC's most recent meeting with the Scottish Chambers of Commerce (SCC) we were advised of a number of issues that are on the SCC’s lobbying 'radar screen'.

  • The UK Government is in the early stages of its consultation on the merger of Income Tax and National Insurance.
  • The Scottish Affairs Committee at Westminster is conducting an inquiry into the Crown estate in Scotland and its impact on Scottish communities.
  • The Scottish Government is planning to update its 'Cities Strategy' under the leadership of Deputy First Minister Nicola Sturgeon.
  • The Scottish Government has also set up a review into university Governance in Scotland.

SCC will want its responses to these issues to be informed by the views of Chamber members across the country, so if you or your organisation has an interest in any of the above and you would like to be kept informed of developments and participate, please let SCC know by contacting Amy Dalrymple on 0141 204 8377 or This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it .

Coming Soon: DACC/SCC Member Policy Briefing Lunches

To ensure that DACC members have an opportunity to influence SCC’s lobbying in the future, we will be organising a quarterly briefing where ‘hot lobbying topics’ will be highlighted and member views captured.  Further details of these events will be sent out in due course but any member who specifically wishes to be involved in these sessions should contact Alan Mitchell at This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it .

 

Budget Reaction

The Chancellor presented his Budget or 'Plan for Growth' yesterday and like every other Budget, it contains what appears on the surface to be a mixture of good and bad measures.

The good news is that there was an emphasis on growing the private sector economy; the Chancellor plans to consult on merging NIC and Income Tax, which would be a major and beneficial simplification of the tax system; there will be a 2% cut in Corporation Tax this year instead of the 1% planned; R&D tax relief for SMEs will be raised; £350m of regulations will be abolished with a moratorium on new regulations for small businesses from 2012; there will be more funding available for apprenticeships; and there will be a 1p cut in fuel duty from today instead of the planned rise.

However the Chancellor announced that he is pressing ahead with the planned increase in Employer NIC rates, which according to his estimates  will increase the cost of hiring someone on a wage of £21,000 or more.  This is likely  to have a disproportionate impact on the high-growth, international business sectors such as games/creative industries, life sciences, advanced manufacturing that the Government says it wants to support, and who generally aren’t in the market for staff earning under £21000.   The Chancellor has also undermined his goal to make the UK business tax  regime the most competitive amongst the G20 economies by choosing to raise taxes for the oil and gas sector to fund the reduction in  fuel duty.   Too often in the past an extra tax on a business sector that is doing well was the easy option for a politician who needed to find money quickly to pay for a politically popular measure.  It would appear the current Government is no exception and that will not encourage inward investment.

The impact of some of the other measures announced in the Budget will only become clear once we know whether they will apply to Scotland and in what form they will be implemented here.  For example, will the Enterprise Zones that are being set up in England be extended to Scotland and what form will they take?   There is going to be extra money available in England to repair pot holes.  Will that automatically generate extra money for Scotland and will the Scottish Government choose to spend any extra money to repair pot holes here?

 

Dundee and Angus: every reason to prepare for a bright future

As I was write this, Scotland is in the middle of a big freeze. I look at the banks of snow piled outside the Chamber office and think to myself: ‘This weather is not what my business needs after what has already been a very difficult year’.  I am sure that I was not alone in thinking this, because 2010 was one of the toughest years that anyone in business can remember (following hot on the heels of an equally tough 2009), and the exceptionally severe weather was not good news for a lot of businesses. But it isn’t doom and gloom for everyone, because the severe winter would actually mean extra customers and orders for some.

That is the thing about business: nothing is ever black and white. No two businesses are exactly the same.  Every organisation has its own unique challenges and they don’t all face the same obstacles at the same time. That is truer of Dundee and Angus than it is of almost the rest of Scotland, because of the diversity of our local economy.  There is no single industry or sector that dominates. Instead, Dundee and Angus boasts a unique ‘patchwork’ of businesses, spanning many different sectors, and that is one of the principal reasons why I believe that Dundee and Angus has a bright future.

In Dundee you will still find successful firms in the sectors that the city is most famous for – the ‘three J’s’ of ‘Jute, Jam and Journalism’.  If you are looking for internationally successful manufacturing and advanced engineering companies, then look no further than Angus, where the number of people employed in the manufacturing sector far exceeds the Scottish average.  (And, despite what you may read elsewhere, manufacturing is still alive and well in Dundee too!)

What about leisure and tourism?  You will find that here too.  Dundee is one of the fastest growing retail destinations in Scotland.   Angus is now starting to see real benefits flowing from Angus Council’s far-sighted, long-term strategy to develop golf tourism, with its ‘Carnoustie Country’ brand growing its visibility, and its sales, in the biggest future market of all: China.  Dundee is home to the 4th biggest nightclub in Britain: I bet you didn’t know that!

This region also benefits from a large public-sector base, with many national organisations headquartered here.  But, Dundee and Angus doesn’t have the same unhealthy dependence on the public sector as other parts of the country.  It is big, and probably bigger than we would like in an ideal world, but not so big that we should fear complete meltdown during the years of public spending ‘austerity’ that lie ahead.  What’s more, the public sector here is often a role model for the rest of Scotland.  NHS Tayside, for example, leads the way in finding cost-effective ways to deliver quality health care to patients.

Social Enterprises – voluntary organisations that develop and exploit a commercial business so that they can be more self sufficient and finically secure – are also well represented in this area, and I never cease to be amazed by their energy, dynamism and innovation.  As the provision of social services by the public sector is scaled back in coming years, I am confident that the region’s social enterprises will be able to step into the breach.
 
Tony Blair famously said that ‘education, education and education’ was his priority, and there is no doubt that it is the foundation of a ‘knowledge economy’.  Again, we can be proud about what is on our doorstep.  Dundee College and Angus College continually win national prizes because of the quality of their teaching and the depth and scale of their engagement with the local business community, which means that local companies can access the skills that they need.   Not many cities with a population of under 150,000 have two universities: but Dundee does.  And, in the University of Dundee and the University of Abertay Dundee, the city has universities that are recognised as being world class, and global leaders in their respective fields of expertise. 

It is our universities’ pioneering leadership that has given this area its newest ‘crown jewels’ – bio/life sciences and digital media/games.  The potential of these sectors is well documented, and their importance to Dundee and Angus cannot be over-stated.   They account for as much as 10% to 15% of the local economy and provide significant numbers of high value ‘knowledge’ jobs.   The highly respected National Endowment for Science Technology and the Arts (NESTA) has said that the way these sectors have grown in Dundee is a role model for developing high-growth ‘new industry’ clusters.

What the NESTA report also highlighted was the successful partnerships that were formed by the key players locally to get these clusters established and on the global map, such as the collaboration between the University of Dundee and NHS Tayside in life sciences. 

This ability to create a genuine partnership and make it work at a practical level underpins many of the good things that are already happening here, and, in my opinion, it gives us a great chance of securing the next big opportunities. 

Dundee is firmly in the running to be the location for an offshoot of the world-famous Victoria & Albert museum, which would be the centrepiece of the ambitious redevelopment of the city’s waterfront.   The very fact that Dundee is even in the running to host an iconic, global brand like the V&A speaks volumes about what the city has to offer.   And, coming back to my earlier point about partnership, it has been a joy to watch everyone pull together to make such a compelling case to bring the V&A here.  

It is the same with renewable energy, with Dundee and Angus firmly in the running to be one of Scotland’s hubs for offshore wind and tidal/wave energy.   Dundee’s port facilities are second to none but no firm will make the multi-million pound investment required to develop manufacturing facilities, and the supply chain that will service them, unless all the hard and soft infrastructure and support they need is in place to sustain their investment.  Dundee and Angus has that infrastructure in spades, and the organisations that will deliver it are already collaborating to make sure that this region can offer an unrivalled portfolio.  A very simple, but powerful, example is the partnership between the local colleges and universities to make sure that every current and future skill that an inward investor will need can be met.

I unashamedly see the ‘glass half full’, and I have no doubts that whatever challenges individual organisations in this area face in the future, Dundee and Angus has every reason to believe it can be successful.  All we need to do is want it enough and work hard enough to make it happen: and I believe that we will.

Alan Mitchell
Chief Executive

 

 
<< Start < Prev 1 2 3 Next > End >>

Page 1 of 3
 
 

Platinum Partners...

Platinum Partner

Follow your chamber here...

facebook linkedin

twitter